Ok so it's been a while since I've posted, due to revision and shit (I have another exam tomorrow. It will be 3 hours of essay writing. My hand hurts just thinking about it) and I have quite a lot to say, but I'm not going to talk about any of it right now. I actually want to talk about something that's partly inspired by a post by
t_asperaand her referring to Hitler as one of the most evil men who ever lived, and also by some arguments I've had a couple of times with my mum.
So here's the thing:
I don't believe in evil.
Not just in an 'I don't believe in Satan' type way, but in an 'I don't believe there is such thing as an evil person' type way. Newspapers do it a lot, especially tabloids. They'll talk about a criminal as a sick, evil individual and stuff like that, and it always jibes strangely with me, because I just don't think it's a description you can use. Nobody is inherently evil. People do bad stuff. Truly, deeply, horrible stuff. And sometimes they do it on purpose, and because they enjoy it. But...to me, I think of 'evilness' as being a total extreme, as doing something
purely because it is evil, and taking joy in it. People in books and movies do that occasionally. You get these figures in fantasy books who are trying to destroy the world or something just because...because they can I guess, I don't know. But you don't get that in real life.
In real life, people can always find some sort of justification for their actions. There's always a reason for it, some way in which they can convince themselves that they have a good reason to do what they do. I don't think Hitler was evil. Hitler believed that everything he did, all that death and destruction he incited - even the Holocaust, though please believe me that I am not trying to be offensive when I say this. I am fully aware of how awful that was, how we don't even have the words to describe it within language. But it is still a part of this - he believed that it was all for a higher purpose, some greater design. He was totally insane, but he believed that. I don't think Osama Bin Laden is evil. I think he believes that he is doing God's work, and that he will be rewarded for it some day.
Nobody thinks of themself as an evil person. Hell yes, I believe that there are evil acts. But unless the person who is committing them is fully aware that what they are doing is evil, can not justify it to themselves in any way, and goes ahead and does it anyway, I don't think you can call a person evil. They're just wrong. Obviously a stronger word would be better there, but I can't think of one right now. 'Misguided' fits even worse. But that's how I feel about it.
Admittedly, I find it a lot harder to justify this theory in terms of paedophiles and rapists and so forth, though I think to some extent even they have found some way to convince themselves that it is somehow ok for them to do this. But people who murder, I think they almost always believe that they have a good reason.
So when I'm reading a book or watching a movie that's using the whole 'good vs evil' plotline (I present Transformers to you. What the hell is going on there? Why is Megatron doing all this again?) I can enjoy it just fine (well, maybe not Transformers...), but it's not something that I can ever use in my own writing. People have light and shade, they have their good traits and their bad traits, but one thing that everyone has in common is that they believe that, somehow, they are the good guys. I don't think the word 'evil' is one that I'm ever going to use seriously, outside of posts like this. But I know a lot of people feel differently.
So I guess at this point I'm going to open it up to you guys. If you're offended by anything I've written here, I'm sorry. I guess I should point out that just because I'm arguing against the use of the word 'evil' here, that doesn't make me in any way less horrified that the stuff I've mentioned here goes on. It just makes me a bit pedantic. But if you want to disagree with me, please do - provided you're polite about it, and I'm sure you all would be anyway, I think all debate is healthy and I'm genuinely interested in seeing what you have to say. I won't be offended by anyone disagreeing with me anyway.
And, poll. Please feel encouraged to discuss as much as you want in the comments as well - I think it'd be really cool to see how different people feel about this.
Poll #1195378 evil
Open to:
All, detailed results viewable to:
AllDo you believe in evil?
If you put 'sort of' or just want to explain your position further, what do you think?